My new book Breast, Bottle or Both, comes out this week. I am thrilled that new parents will have non-judgmental support and guidance in all aspects of feeding their baby. I am also really nervous. Why? Because strangers online are likely to share their very strong opinions about why a lactation consultant should not talk about bottles and formula.
If I am feeling this stress, I imagine that many of you do too. I have seen new mums pass bottles of ready made formula under tables in cafes in case somebody sees them. I hear every day from parents who are made to feel guilty about their feeding decisions. We are unkind to ourselves and others.
Baby feeding decisions can be complicated and nuanced and they have to work for the family. When you see someone breast or bottle feeding, you do not know their story. In the last few months I have worked with:
- many new parents who need their baby to take a bottle sometimes, so that the mother can rest, work, go out or attend to other family commitments
- wonderful partners, who find bottle feeding a fantastic and joyful way to spend time with their newborn and give the mothers a break
- mothers who need their babies to take bottles so that they can work and support their family
- mothers who could not make enough breastmilk due to breast or hormone issues, or as a result of unhelpful or inadequate advice in managing feeding in the early days
- anxious and overwhelmed parents who are scared their baby needs more food and feel unable to access the support they need when they feel most worried, so give bottle top ups
- several mothers whose nipples are too sore to feed just now due to their baby’s birth injuries or tongue-ties, and are bottle feeding expressed milk while waiting for referrals
- mothers with such squirty breasts and squirmy babies that they cannot face breastfeeding in public so give bottles when out and about
- parents of babies with newborn jaundice who need to give their sleepy babies bottles to help them get better
- parents of twins who desperately need someone else to bottle feed one of the premature babies while they focus on breastfeeding the other
- a new mum with severe PTSD from a terrifying birth, who suffered huge blood loss and also has limited breast tissue. She was desperate to breast feed and is doing, but also needs to top up with formula
- a mum with MS who needs some hospital treatment and knows from experience she will be too unwell to breastfeed
- an autistic mother who feels too overwhelmed to exclusively breastfeed but might be able to do some, as long as her partner can do some bottles
- a new family waiting to meet their baby being carried by a surrogate. After multiple miscarriages and lots of unsuccessful IVF, the parents don’t want to take hormones to induce lactation
- several mothers feeding after breast reduction surgery, and needing to top up with formula
This is not an exhaustive list.
New parents cry because they feel so judged about breast or bottle feeding, and so sad when they know that “breast is best” but it isn’t working for them.
Babies thrive when they are fed and loved. Sometimes bottles of expressed milk or formula are absolutely critical. A lot of the time, they are desirable. My role is to support new parents to feed responsively and safely. Individually and as a society we need to nurture new parents, helping them to build loving relationships with their babies.
Having trouble with bottle feeding, or your feelings around it? Please reach out to me for a consultation.
Buy my book on Amazon here.
