When I sit down with a new mum to talk about feeding, she almost inevitably reaches for her phone.
“Look, his feeds lasted an average of 29 minutes yesterday, four hours forty seven minutes in total, and here he was overtired in his wake window, and he didn’t get a full feed at 10.30 am… “
Sometimes she won’t begin a feed until she’s pressed the left breast button and started her timer, regardless of what else is going on with her baby in that moment.
I wonder out loud whether the tracking is helping.
“I’m so tired that I won’t remember otherwise. It helps me to know when he might need his next feed, and where he is in his routine.”
The anxious parents sit and analyse the data, pointing out the periods of cluster feeding and asking me whether their baby is normal. And my heart sinks a little bit, as I wonder where they got these largely unsubstantiated ideas of full feeds and wake windows and sleep cycles and routines.
First, I understand that in the first few days of your baby’s life, a tracker app can be super helpful. You’re exhausted and all over the place. Your midwives frequently ask you about nappy output and how many feeds you have done. But after that, when your baby is thriving, I wonder whether apps set the expectation of control over a profoundly complex system which works nicely on its own in most cases?
What’s normal for a baby?
Your baby loves to suck. It’s their best way to get fed, relax, reconnect with you, pass wind, relieve pain, warm up on your body, go to and stay asleep. Breastfeeding mothers often complain that their baby is “using me like a dummy” but quite honestly they’re relying on you as a mummy. When I sit with breastfeeding families I notice how the mother monitors her baby. When her baby gets distressed they clearly both yearn to feed. As soon as they do, I can see and feel the wave of oxytocin calming them both. Nature is wonderful. Responsive bottle feeding does this too, the caregiver visibly relaxing as their baby calms with the bottle and begins to suck, or drops off to sleep at the end of the feed.
When we look for robust evidence around wake windows, full feeds and routines, we’re not going to find it. These are ideas that sell, not scientific truths. What happens if we buy into suggestions that there needs to be a routine, a decent gap between feeds, full feeds and no snacks? Parents and babies lose their key way of adapting milk volumes, connecting and coregulating. If we insist on a predetermined pattern your baby cannot boost their milk intake when having a growth spurt, have a mouthful of milk in hot weather, calm down while their busy brain and body are learning and building. In most cases their complex systems can regulate beautifully with yours changing day by day if you let them.
Tracking apps give us, and the companies that own them, huge amounts of data. I find that parents who are project managers, accountants and medics, my autistic clients and systematisers, love the data. The problem is that babies are complex and ever changing systems. You provide the same inputs, do everything by the book, and get different behaviour. It can be maddening. The bottom line is that life as a parent to a new baby is exhausting and unpredictable and it will probably be the first time you’ve been properly out of control. At times you’ll think you’re going mad. And it’s totally normal.
Some of you will have friends and family members whose babies slot perfectly into a routine. Perhaps their baby drinks huge bottles and sleeps well in between. When you meet up these parents suggest that you do what they do, and your sleep deprived brain leaps with joy at the thought that you could have this life too. But your baby is wired different. Perhaps your baby only need ten hours of sleep in 24 hours, is more sensitive and need more cuddles and contact naps, or your breasts have lower storage capacity so your baby needs more frequent feeds? The expectations of predictability make you think that you and your baby are doing something wrong when actually you’re one of the many versions of normal.
It is worth remembering that tracking apps are not benign. The companies running them now know minute to minute what is going on in your home. They are especially keen to predict when you’ll be awake in the night and most vulnerable to adverts. New parents are an incredibly valuable target market. I wonder whether this suggestion of routine might start an anxious spiral about not having sufficient breastmilk, and perhaps more (lucrative) bottle feeding, in families where breastfeeding was actually working?
If the tracking app is undermining your instincts or confidence, you might gently put it to one side and reconcile yourself to the wonderful, natural, chaos that’s now part of your life as a new parent.
In the immortal words of Douglas Adams in The Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy:
“There is a theory which states that if ever anyone discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable.
There is another theory which states that this has already happened.”
The instant you think you’ve got parenting sorted, the same thing applies.
If you have any concerns about feeding your new baby please reach out to me or another IBCLC trained to help you understand all elements of your baby’s feeding. This article can only be general information, your medical practitioners are the best people to discuss the health of you and your baby.
To book a free chat or consultation with me, click here.
For more on the science of sleep and caring for your baby at night, BASIS online provides excellent evidence based information.