As a lactation consultant, I am widely expected to promote breastfeeding, and of course I help families with this. Breastmilk is the optimal food for human babies and breastfeeding can be awesome.
However, bottle feeding is a vital part of many families’ feeding journey regardless of whether the bottle contains breastmilk or infant formula. New parents often tell me they feel judged, guilty or unsupported in bottle feeding their baby. They talk fof midwives or health visitors rolling their eyes, negative looks or comments as they bottle feed in public, being told to “figure it out” on their own.
Bottle feeding can be a beautiful bonding experience
Many parents, friends and family members describe their time bottle feeding the little one as some of the best moments of their life. I am not exaggerating.

Partners and friends can share parenting
Bottle feeding allows other caregivers the opportunity to feed the baby and look after them for longer periods.
As shared parental leave becomes more common, bottle feeding is often a necessity.
Single parents particularly appreciate the support of other special people in their lives who can bottle feed the baby.
Parents who have adopted a child, or had a child with the support of a surrogate, are most likely to exclusively bottle feed although some chose to induce lactation as well.
When mother and baby need to be separated
There are many short and longer term reasons why a woman might not be by her baby’s side. Early in a baby’s life, it is often when a baby is an inpatient in hospital but the mother has been discharged. On occasions it is the mother who is too unwell to breastfeed her baby, or her milk has been delayed by her medical condition.
In everyday life it is perfectly reasonable for a mother to want or need to attend an engagement on her own. She might need a break even if she is not leaving the house. A rested, happy and fulfilled mother is a better mother and everyone benefits.
Gives the mother the opportunity to fulfil other roles
Very often a woman will want or need to work outside the home, or undertake other duties with family or the community.
A brilliant addition or alternative when breastfeeding is not working out
Good bottle feeding can be much more relaxing for everyone than painful or troubled breastfeeding. Offering bottles of expressed milk or formula can allow the mother time to heal. For some, switching to bottles can be a huge relief.
Provides confidence over a baby’s milk intake
It can be medically necessary, and is often desirable, to know how much a baby is drinking.
Sometimes a little more structure to the day
Bottle feeding can be more predictable than breastfeeding. There is slightly more chance that the baby will get into a pattern of feeding and sleeping that provides a little more certainty in life.
Allowing the birthing mother to rest and recover
A well-rested mother tends to have more resilience, patience and energy than one at her wit’s end with exhaustion. Shared feeding can be vital, especially when she has numerous competing responsibilities.
When the mother is taking medication, has a medical condition that is incompatible with breastfeeding, or takes street drugs
Bottle feeding can be medically essential. I have worked with families where the mother is too unwell to breastfeed or the exhaustion of being wholly responsible for the baby could result in a flare up of a medical condition like MS or epilepsy.
Some medical conditions could necessitate a woman pumping milk to bottle feed the baby.
Breastfeeding is not advised for women taking:
· Antiretroviral medications (for HIV/AIDS treatment)
· Cancer chemotherapy agents
· Illegal drugs
· Certain medications prescribed to treat migraines, such as ergot alkaloids
· Mood stabilizers, such as lithium and lamotrigine
· Sleep-aid medicines
Formula feeding is indicated for women with HIV, human T-cell lymphotropic virus type I or type II, and untreated, active tuberculosis.
Sometimes there is a need to bottle feed temporarily if the mother needs forms of radiation therapy or surgery.
A preference for many trans parents
Many parents with gender dysphoria or those who are trans may choose to bottle feed, possibly alongside some chest feeding.
Ability to engage paid help
Those employing a maternity nurse, night nurse or other baby care professional generally appreciate the flexibility of bottle feeding.
Allowing shared care of twins and multiple babies
Bottle feeding can be an essential part of caring for multiple babies.
In situations where the mother cannot provide breastmilk
Many women are not able to produce any, or sufficient breastmilk for their baby. In my practice I work with women who have: insufficient glandular tissue, extensive breast surgeries, hormone conditions, the need for other non-compatible medication, major post partum haemorrhage, retained products of conception…the list goes on. Sometimes we just do not know why a woman cannot fully feed her baby. Often it is a complex interplay of factors.
Bottle feeding might allow more breastfeeding
Many women say that when the pressure to fully breastfeed is removed, it allows them to give some breastmilk for longer.
Reduces maternal anxiety and allows more control
The mental health implications of breastfeeding can be too great for many women. I work with mothers whose anxiety levels do not allow them to cope with the uncertainty and unpredictability of breastfeeding. They need to know how much milk their baby is getting, and to have some control over when that might happen. It might be critical that they have more than five hours of sleep in a row each night to maintain their mental health.
Many mothers need to bottle feed because of their OCD or systematising traits, eating disorder, body dysphoria, sensory issues or autism. Some women experience awful emotional and physical sensations as the milk lets down. Others find that breast feeding makes their skin crawl.
Women who have experienced past sexual abuse and trauma may understandably prefer to bottle feed.
When the baby cannot breastfeed
There are numerous situations where a little one is not able to breastfeed, either for short or longer term reasons. Various medical conditions can make a baby too small, jaundiced, sleepy, uncoordinated or structurally unable to breastfeed. Issues with oral anatomy or physiology may mean that bottles or even nasogastric tubes are vital for feeding in the early days.
Babies who were in a restricted position in the womb, or arrived with the help of instruments like forceps, might feed too uncomfortable to breastfeed for a while.
When the baby needs a top up
Many babies require top ups of breastmilk or formula to allow them to grow sufficiently. This can be short term, for example when a newborn baby is sleepy with jaundice, or longer term when a baby is not reaching the growth milestones.
When weaning away from breastfeeding
Some women breastfeed for a certain amount of time and then decide to bottle feed.
If a baby requires specialist milk
Rarely, a baby will require feeds of fortified or otherwise specialist milk to combat poor weight gain, an allergy or medical condition.
If you are reading this as an expectant or new parent, I hope that you feel brilliantly informed, supported and good about your feeding decisions. I appreciate that bottle feeding might not have been your first choice, and that you might be upset about your pre- or postnatal experiences and feel emotional about the decision.
If you would like to reach out to me for tailored support on your own situation, you can do this from my website Cathy Sage. You might also like to read my book Breast Bottle or Both on Amazon.
For help with selecting infant feeding bottles and formula click here.
If you are worried that your baby might get confused between breast and bottle, you can read ore here.
And for the top ten reasons for bottle refusal, read more here.
