In the UK a standard first formula labelled 1 of any brand will suit most babies. Ready to feed formula is considered safest for your baby in the first two months.
Many parents find anxiety levels rising when confronted with the huge choice of formula milks available.
The key point is that newborn infants need either liquid or powdered formula that is suitable from birth, which will be labelled 1. This is appropriate all through your baby’s first year, after which your baby can be offered full fat cow’s milk instead.
Marketing claims on formula packets can be misleading. The basic contents are heavily regulated. Additional components in “premium” brands may not be better for your baby. The research indicates that the cheaper brands are just as good as the high price brands.
Formulas labelled “follow on formula,” “hungry baby,” “goodnight formula,” or “lactose free” are not recommended. In many cases they are an inferior product to standard number 1 formula, even though they are often more expensive. Parents are advised not to use specialist formula such as lactose free or soy. If a baby needs specialist formula in the UK it will be prescribed by a doctor.
The organisation First Steps Nutrition Trust has published independent research into infant formula. Their reports are free to download from their website. I have summarised their information in this guide.
Shall I use ready to feed, tabs or powdered formula?
The World Health Organisation suggests ready to use formula is the safest option for babies under two months.
Pre-prepared bottled formula is generally convenient and has the advantage of being sterile until is it opened. Formula feeding parents will be asked to bring ready to feed liquid formula into hospital. Formula for the very early days is generally sold in newborn size bottles with sterile single use teats that can be applied straight to the bottle. These teats are often very fast flow for a tiny baby.
When you are at home, you could pour out the required amount of formula into the sterilised feeding bottle you have chosen and put the remainder in the back of the fridge where it stays usable for 24 hours. I suggest that you write the time and date that you have opened any type of formula onto the packaging.
Parents like ready to feed formula because:
- It has no preparation time, unless you chose to warm it
- It is stable and can be placed in a cupboard until needed
- There is no need to worry about getting the preparation wrong
- It is least likely to contain harmful bacteria if used correctly
- It does not go off after a month, like an open box of powder
- You do not have to shake it, so it may result in a less bubbly product
- It is readily portable
The downsides of ready prepared formula:
- The cost! It is much more expensive to feed a baby this way
- It takes up much more space in your home
- There is a higher environmental impact from transporting liquids and associated plastic waste
- Some parents are concerned by the stabilisers and emulsifiers added to these products to help maintain their consistency and extend shelf life
Powdered formula is a more cost-effective option than ready mixed formula. It is important to make the formula correctly using boiled fresh tap water that is still over 70°C, and then cool the bottle for the baby. The issue is bacteria in the formula powder, not the water. Recent university-led research suggests that most parents do not make infant formula correctly, and that many bottle preparation machines may not be heating water sufficiently to kill bacteria in the formula powder. This is of particular concern when babies are premature or unwell.
Formula pre-measured tabs reduce the chance that parents will spoon out the formula incorrectly, pack it wrongly or use the wrong amounts. They are more expensive that standard powdered formula, but cheaper than ready to feed formula.
In an emergency when safe tap water is not available, bottled table water is considered the next best alternative.
How should I select a formula brand?
All formula sold in the UK for newborns will be labelled with a 1. It is heavily regulated. This means that any of the brands will be appropriate for your baby.
Although all the number one products are suitable for your baby, there are some minor differences in their ingredients for example the types of oils they use. You might find that your baby prefers one brand over another, and you may notice that different products have a slightly different thickness and smell to them.
Is organic formula better?
We have little evidence that organic formula is better for your baby’s health.
Several brands such as Kendamil and Hipp offer formula made with organic milk. While there is little evidence that this is significantly better for your baby, it might sit well with your own ethics on farming and animal welfare standards.
Is Comfort formula good for my baby’s tummy problems?
There is no convincing evidence to suggest that these milks are effective in preventing colic, wind, gastrointestinal discomfort, or constipation.
Several well known formula brands offer a “comfort” milk. Babies do not need the hydrolysed proteins they contain to make infant formula easier to digest.
Comfort milks play on parents’ fears and experience of babies with “tummy troubles.” It is normal for newborn babies to have wind and instances of gastric discomfort, and to have unsettled periods in the evenings. When babies fuss it is often called colic, but this is not a recognised medical diagnosis. Several recent reviews have reported that there is not enough evidence to use any specialist formula for the relief of colic, and the NHS advice relies entirely on practical and soothing strategies. We discuss colic and reflux here.
Shall I buy formula for “hungry babies”?
No.
Many parents are tempted by formula marketed for “hungry babies.” These formulas give the impression that your baby will stay fuller for longer and perhaps sleep better. There is no evidence to support this.
Hungry baby formula is dominated by casein rather than whey, which might be slightly harder to digest. As there is so little evidence of any benefit, First Steps Nutrition Trust recommends that these formulas are only used under the guidance of a health professional.
Do anti-reflux milks work?
Anti-reflux milks are best avoided. We have very little evidence showing benefits of anti-reflux milks in otherwise healthy babies. Babies who need specialist milk will be prescribed it by the doctor.
Most babies bring up some milk at times, and this is called reflux. Bothhttps://cathysage.com/why-is-my-baby-spitting-up/ spit ups and occasional vomits are common in newborn babies and can continue for months, although they tend to start getting better after about three months as the gut matures. While regurgitation can feel alarming for parents, very few babies require any further investigation, treatment or a change from number one formula.
Anti-reflux milks are based on cow’s milk but contain a thickener which is usually potato starch, carob or locust bean gum. These milks are marketed as foods for special medical purposes and should only be used under medical supervision. If you feel that your baby is struggling with reflux, please seek out specialist feeding support first to investigate exactly what is happening for your baby. Sometime a change in teat, angle, pace, amount or frequency of feeds can make a significant difference. Most babies will grow out of it.
If your baby continues to show significant, frequent regurgitation with clear distress, your doctor might suggest that a thickener is given on a spoon or that you have a trial of thickened formula. There is some evidence that these thickeners can reduce the amount of regurgitation, but there is very limited evidence to support them as a “cure” for reflux.
Powdered anti-reflux milks appear to go lumpy when made with hot water, and the manufacturers suggest using water under 70oC. This is not in line with current recommendations for making up powdered infant formula safely.

Should I buy soy formula?
Soya-protein formula is not recommended for babies under six months.
Soya is a common cause of allergy in new babies. There are concerns that phytoestrogens in soya may impact sexual maturation. These formulas are also more likely to damage your baby’s teeth. Although they are in supermarkets, please do not use these products unless medically recommended.
Is rice formula suitable for my baby?
No.
Rice milk formula should not be used for babies or children under five years old.
Is goat’s milk formula better than cow’s milk?
Cow’s milk and goat’s milk formula are similar.
Several brands of formula are made from goat’s milk, and they claim to be easier to digest or kinder to baby’s stomach. We have no evidence for this. Very rarely babies are allergic to the protein in either cow’s or goat’s milk, there is no difference.
How would I know if my baby was allergic to cow’s or goat’s milk?
It is very unusual for a baby to have an allergy to cow’s or goat’s milk. If your baby shows signs of an immediate and severe reaction when they are given formula, call 999 for an ambulance. If symptoms are mild, call your doctor.
Reactions are typically seen when babies have formula for the first time. The allergy might be immediate, within minutes of drinking the milk, or delayed by hours or even days.
Very rarely, cow’s or goat’s milk can cause severe allergy symptoms that come on rapidly. This is a medical emergency. Call 999 for an ambulance if your baby has swelling in the mouth or throat, wheezing, cough, shortness of breath, and difficult, noisy breathing.
Some allergic babies will need to be prescribed an extensively hydrolysed formula. In rare and complex cases, a baby might be prescribed an amino-acid based formula.
When will I need Follow-on formula?
Follow-on formula labelled 2 or 3 is not required. It should never be given to babies under six months, and there is no evidence that parents need to switch to follow on formula after six months.
Follow on formula contains slightly more iron than number 1 formula, but babies will be eating appropriate foods after six months and will not benefit from the additional iron.
Children over one year can be given whole cow’s or goat’s milk but do not need toddler growing up milks. Some fortified but unsweetened plant “milks” such as oat milk are also suitable. Please check First Steps Nutrition Trust online for the latest scientific information on this.
Shall I buy lactose-free formula?
No. Lactose intolerance is rare in babies, so only a very small number of babies will benefit from lactose-free infant formula given under medical supervision.
Brands including Aptamil and SMA offer a lactose free formula. Please do not self-diagnose lactose intolerance in your baby or buy lactose-free formula just in case. Parents who suffer with lactose intolerance are unlikely to have a newborn with lactose intolerance.
A baby struggling with lactose intolerance will be extremely unwell. If your baby is diagnosed as lactose intolerant, they will be prescribed appropriate formula by the doctor.
Some babies get temporary (secondary) lactose intolerance after a tummy bug, when their parents will notice green poos and discomfort for a few days. This resolves by itself and there is no evidence that lactose-free milk is beneficial in these cases.
Lactose free milks use glucose syrup as the source of carbohydrate. The glucose syrup can cause tooth decay, so parents need to be careful with brushing their baby’s teeth. It could also cause changes in gut bacteria that impact on gut function and calcium absorption.
Can I make my own homemade formula?
Absolutely not. This could be very dangerous for your baby’s health.
You might read recipes for homemade formula online. Please do not make your own formula. It is extremely difficult to get the right balance of constituents mixed appropriately, and there is a high risk of long term, irreversible harm to your baby.
If you are worried about your baby’s bottle feeding, please book a call or consultation with me here.
It would be lovely to hear from you.
