What do bottle refusal and coffee drinking have in common?
Every day, someone asks me why their baby won’t happily take a bottle. They tell me that they have tried everything: different bottles, teats and flow rates, times of day, other people giving the bottle, different types and temperatures of milk, distraction techniques. Nothing seems to work. By the time they get to me, exhausted breastfeeding parents are at their wits’ end.
Reflecting on this, I thought about my coffee. I love coffee. I like it in the morning when I wake up. I like it mid-morning as I catch up with friends. Sometimes I grab a strong coffee after lunch, other times a creamy latte assuages mid afternoon munchies. I like it while snuggled on the sofa before bed. If I am thirsty, especially on a hot day, I like it over ice. If I am under the weather I choose it volcanic and rich. Some days I snatch a quick one and drink it fast, other days I linger with my companions and might even order a second.
The key thing is, I get to choose. I can vary the creaminess and sugar content. I choose how fast to drink it. I pause and catch my breath. I stop to connect with my family and friends. I feel better if I am sitting in a comfy chair and can rest my feet. I prefer not to drink it in a plastic cup or through a straw. I prefer my coffee in a relatively quiet place where I can hear myself think, not a jangly sports bar with the TV on very loud.
Nobody ever wakes me for a coffee (if they know what is good for them). Nobody forces me to have a coffee I don’t want even if it is coffee time. Nobody ever holds my mouth open to make me drink or finish it.
Babies are the same.
No healthy baby mammal needs their parent to tell them when to eat or how much to have. They instinctively know. A complex interaction of reflexes, bodily sensations, receptors and hormones keep everything in balance. Left to it, healthy human babies adjust their milk intake through the days and weeks depending on their hunger. They figure out how to get more milk, fattier milk, faster flowing milk or reducing the flow, all by themselves. They know when they are hungry and thirsty, and when they are full. They have limited ability to communicate, but they will do so if we watch and listen.
Just like my coffee habits, babies use feed times to connect, to snuggle up and relax, for pain relief and comfort. In close contact with their parents, they easily pick up on parental levels of stress or relaxation. Breastfeeding is designed to be calming for both mother and baby.
So now we bring in a bottle. And baby might not like it.
Let’s think about it from your baby’s point of view. Your baby is held in an unfamiliar position, often with a hand on the back of their head or neck, spine free and their feet unsupported. Alternatively, they might be propped in a chair or even car seat with their head tipped slightly forward. They might feel a bib being put around their neck. They might be restrained. None of it feels like a snuggly breastfeeding position.
The bottle teat feels cold, hard and unfamiliar. They have an instinct to spit it out. The teat might make them gag, especially if they have a high palate.
When your baby breastfeeds, they start sucking to encourage the breasts to let down milk. Some bottles start dripping or pouring milk before your baby is ready. If they do not have a good seal on the bottle, the surprise arrival of milk can make them cough or choke. Conversely, some bottles release milk so slowly that your baby might not figure out there is milk available at all.
Your baby might not have the skills to bottle feed. Their unique tongue and palate shape could be challenging. If your baby is older than eight weeks they have lost their initial suck reflex. It might be very difficult for them to position their tongue to stabilise the bottle and get milk out, and to pass the milk to the back of their mouth to be swallowed. If the bottle teat is the wrong shape for them there might be gaps at the sides of their mouth, or their lips might be pressed at a funny angle. Air might get in, so they can’t swallow well, or they swallow air along with the milk. Milk might leak from the sides of their mouth.
Your baby might object to the flow being wrong, or the taste or temperature of the milk.
Worst of all, they can’t stop the flow. Breastmilk comes out in pulses, slowing down a bit with time. Milk from a bottle just keeps coming even when your baby wants to stop sucking to take a break or burp or connect. Your baby might be asking you to stop, by crying or twisting their head or spitting out milk. They might close their mouth tight shut. If they can’t get away, they might cough or choke, or even vomit. They might make fists or splay their fingers or kick their legs or arch back.
Feeding like this can result in more gas in your baby, which feels uncomfortable for them.
In rare instances, the cow’s milk in formula milk causes an intolerance or allergy, so the milk gives your baby a tummy ache.
You are probably very keen for your baby to feed as suggested on the packet instructions. You might feel like you need to wake your baby to feed, or insist on a feeding schedule, even if your baby is not hungry. You might strongly encourage or insist that your baby finishes their bottle, regardless of their feeding cues.
Bottle feeding can feel stressful for everyone. Your baby feels your stress. After a while, they can get averse to even seeing a bottle or being held in a bottle feeding position.
Please be clear, I am not saying this because I am against bottles. I think bottle skills are vital for babies and their parents. Bottle feeding keeps babies fed and parents sane. I know that you want your baby to be happy and healthy and to grow well.
You can see that healthy babies can have trouble bottle feeding for many reasons. We need to look at what is going on and find the best ways to solve their problems and overcome aversions.
If your baby is premature, ill, or is having medical problems, please get specialist support before attempting to bottle feed.
How do we build bottle skills?
First, we must all be on the same side. This is not a fight between parent and baby. Your baby is not choosing this, they are not capable of being wilful or manipulative. Your baby is trying to communicate with you, and it is up to you to listen. In my view, developing bottle skills should be a calm, kind and respectful process. Everyone is learning a new skill.
1. Select kit that works for your baby
Look at the way your baby breastfeeds. What seems like an appropriate flow rate? Although most brands of bottles come with slow, medium and fast flow teats, there is huge variation. If you are not sure about the flow of the teat you have, try sucking on it yourself.
Offer your baby a bottle teat in its ring to suck on. Can your baby make a seal on it? Are their lips turned out and relaxed? If they can’t do it, it is not the right teat for them, or they need a lot more practice.
2. Select a milk that your baby likes, serve it at body temperature (about 37ºC)
Try bottle feeding with expressed milk first, if possible. Most number one infant formula for newborns tastes similar. Prescription specialist milks can taste horrible, and there might be a process of mixing it with expressed breastmilk to get baby used to it (whatever your doctor recommends).
3. Try to make a bottle feed like a breastfeed
Wait for your baby to be hungry and showing feeding cues like smacking their lips and rooting.
Hold your baby securely so their body is relaxed. Make eye contact, have a soothing chat with them. Babies often do best with their back and feet securely touching something.
Warm the milk. Dip the teat in some milk so it tastes nice. Try holding the bottle upside down (with your clean finger over the hole) so it warms up the teat.
Offer the teat by stroking your baby’s top lip with it. Wait until they invite the bottle in.
Let them suck on the empty teat for at least a few seconds before angling the bottle up so they can take the milk.
Watch them carefully. When they stop sucking, lower the angle of the bottle again. Wait for them to catch their breath and ask for more milk, then raise it again.
Bottle feeding should take roughly five minutes per 30 mls.
When your baby has had enough, respect that. Allow your baby chance to burp.
Watch for further feeding cues. Only offer your baby more milk if they show signs of wanting it.
Please never force a bottle into closed lips, or make baby finish what is left in a bottle if they do not want it. If your baby is crying, stop the feed.
4. Keep realistic expectations
Formula and bottle manufacturers must give you a rough idea of what a healthy baby might take during a bottle feed, and the expected frequency of feeds. They must cater for even the biggest and hungriest babies, and they know that parents prefer fewer bigger feeds.
However, you might assume that your baby must take a certain amount at each feed, or be fed on a strict schedule. In my experience, this sets up unrealistic expectations. Just like adults, babies like to decide how much they eat and when. Nearly all would prefer smaller, more frequent feeds than the formula packets suggest. We can be responsive and baby led with formula feeding, just like breastfeeding. Keep an eye on your baby’s nappy output and weight, as you would with any child.
What if none of this is working?
We might be dealing with an aversion, where we need to reestablish trust.
There could be something going on with your baby, such as being unwell or unable to take a bottle. Please reach out for skilled support from an IBCLC with training in this area.
Will your bottle refusing baby ever take a bottle? There is a lot we can do to help them. We have assessments, activities and exercises that can help to build their skills. After four months old, we can work with cups too. Please reach out for skilled support.
Some babies never love bottles. Most will take enough out of them to be well fed overall.
For help in improving your baby’s bottle skills, please call me on 07720 425 897 or book here.
