Bottle feeding isn’t the easy option!
I have worked with thousands of bottle feeding parents. You are not alone with your worries.
Here are the top ten things bottle feeding parents stress about.
1. Guilt
Whether bottle feeding was a positive choice or forced upon you, you may feel guilty and judged. In the way your Health Visitor seems to roll her eyes when you talk about it, the fact you are left alone to figure bottles out for yourself, the disappointed or sympathetic comments from your family and friends who have breastfed, when you’re told yet again that exclusive breastfeeding is the best thing for your baby.
I hope that you are bottle feeding with positivity and joy, knowing that it’s a good choice for you and your family.
If bottle feeding was not your plan, you may be processing loss or sadness over what might have been possible had things had worked out differently. You might be justifiably angry about the series of events that got you here.
If breastfeeding is fine but you still want to bottle feed, it can be even more guilt-inducing. Parents often feel the need to justify it to me. They tell me that they’re stressed about the bottles but need a break, to leave the home, to get some sleep, to share baby bonding opportunities with other loving adults. They’re often terrified that if something happened to them, their baby would starve.
These are all very valid reasons to introduce bottles! If your baby needs a bottle so you can go on a hen do or to a Taylor Swift concert, spend time with another child or to get your nails done, you do you! I’m delighted for you. All these things make you better able to be a good (enough) mum the rest of the time. Anxiety about being the sole carer can be profound. Many mothers are in tears when they share their emotions around this.
The worst guilt can happen when a breastfed baby needs to take a bottle to go to nursery or to someone else. This might be the first time a mother is leaving her baby for long periods, and it can feel extremely difficult even if she’s looking forward to the “freedom” at the same time. Breastfed babies can struggle with the transition to bottles, putting huge strain on a mother who knows that her little one relies on her for emotional regulation and food.
If you’re in this situation, feeling trapped and terrified about what might happen when you’re not there, please reach out for support. Just so you know, healthy babies don’t starve themselves. Whatever happens your baby will get fed.
2. Failure
Sometimes breastfeeding doesn’t work out. Even if it’s something you’d desperately like to do, and prepared for, other things can get in the way.
You might have experienced a difficult birth, physical or emotional trauma, an unwell baby, a low milk supply. You might have been instructed to formula feed if your baby was sick, jaundiced, not growing as expected, and you didn’t have breastmilk available. Over those important early days you might have been too unwell, exhausted, overwhelmed, isolated or not informed to express sufficiently to bring in your full milk supply. It’s not your fault.
The stories I find hardest to hear are when a baby was not thriving on breastfeeding but it wasn’t picked up. Seeing their precious baby in A&E, or admitted to NICU, can demolish a woman’s confidence in her ability to nurture her baby. This should not be happening, the system is letting you down.
If this is you, please be kind to yourself. Your baby needs to be fed and loved and you need to be ok. Your baby will thrive on whatever number one formula you give and breastmilk is a bonus if you have it. Read more about feelings of failure here.
3. Baby’s feeding schedule
Bottle feeding gives parents the illusion of control. In theory, you decide when your baby feeds and you get to know the volumes. You might be given a schedule or want to follow a routine. In more complex medical situations a feeding plan can be essential. Parents of multiples often need routines. However, there are problems with overthinking or obsessing over routines and volumes when your baby is otherwise well.
Bottle feeding to a fixed schedule sometimes overrides natural instincts and feeding cues. I meet many parents who won’t start a feed unless they’ve checked the time and set their tracking app. Who say “oh, he can’t be hungry yet, it’s only been two hours” when their baby is frantically signalling for food.
Ideally, you would bottle feed responsively, when your baby is hungry, rather than on a strict routine. If your baby is well, they should be able to signal to you with feeding cues like rooting and sucking their fingers.
Despite what you may have been told, your baby didn’t read about full feeds or wake windows. There is no scientific evidence that babies need feeding and sleep routines. Baby mammals are programmed to be on their mothers waking and feeding multiple times day and night. It is not normal or kind to refuse your baby food outside set feeding times. You do not need to artificially stretch the time between feeds. Your baby will sleep more at night when they’re ready to. While this can feel unpredictable and exhausting it is the biological norm. We need to manage our expectations of what we expect to achieve in these early days. We need to ask for and accept a lot of help.
4. Achieving recommended daily volumes
Many parents stress about their baby taking the recommended amount of milk from the bottle. This is often worse when a baby had a bumpy start, did not grow well or has previously been admitted to hospital for dehydration. It’s terrifying for parents who will do anything to avoid a repeat of the experience.
You’d imagine that there is clear cut science about volumes of breast milk or formula to offer. But there isn’t. You’ll notice quite quickly that health organisations and formula manufacturers don’t agree on how much a baby a should drink from a bottle either per feed or in 24 hours, especially after the first month of life.
I expect your baby might take more some feeds than others and vary their daily amounts. The good news is that, within reason, we can trust a healthy baby human to ask for and take what they need, our job is to offer and respond when we see feeding cues.
It can feel terribly difficult to be led by your baby when you are anxious. And of course you have good reason to be anxious especially when feeding isn’t going to plan. I work with many parents struggling with broader issues, for example related to OCD or neuro divergence. Sleep deprivation makes everything so much harder. Those who have lived with their own eating disorders need particular support. I’ve met many who restrict their baby’s intake.
Babies can be prone to spitting up. Healthy babies are rarely bothered by it and are good at clearing it even when lying on their back. You can read more about it here. However, it is common for their parents to find this intolerable. The main worries are about choking, or the baby losing too much milk. Neither are usually a problem. Please talk to medical professionals if your baby seems unwell, is losing all of their feeds, is not growing as expected, or you are otherwise worried.
Adults who struggle with a phobia about vomiting (emetophobia) find life with a baby especially challenging. The phobia is common but rarely talked about, and in my experience it can make parents prone to underfeeding. Please reach out for support around this.
Over feeding is more likely when parents have expectations about growth curves, routines, babies learning independence, and how other people’s babies are doing. Again, you might need to talk to someone about this.
Some books, maternity nurses and sleep consultants promise things that are super appealing but not physiologically normal, like getting your baby to sleep for really long periods by encouraging big feeds. This might work for some babies but you should know it’s not normal or expected behaviour. I would hate you to feel like a failure when your baby starts to resist feeling super full, finds feeding boring and annoying, or has a normal sleep regression.
In my experience, professionals with a science, medical or data driven background are especially affected by needing to monitor inputs and outputs. They are wonderful at problem solving in their career, and this might be the first time they have been truly out of control of their lives! Tracking apps can be a helpful tool in the early days but may lead to an obsession.
Please talk about how you’re feeling and your own struggles and worries. Voicing it can really help. Your NHS and other supporters have resources to assist you. Nobody will think you’re mad or take your baby away. I promise we see this a lot and you deserve compassionate support.
5. How to manage pumping
Expressing milk can do your head in. Especially if you’re also trying to do anything else like recover, care for other people, bring up a baby, and maintain sanity. Triple feeding, where a mother breastfeeds, expresses and bottle feeds, is a particular form of torture. Even with fantastic support, nobody should be expected to do this for more than a few days.
If this is your scenario, let’s get practical. Please get skilled support for the breastfeeding part so you can maximise efficiency.
Think clearly about what type of pump suits you, how effective it is, and how many pumps a day is realistic. Skipping it all in the late evening in favour of sleep might work if you have another adult around to bottle feed at that time.
It is rarely possible to look after a baby by yourself and also pump several times a day. If you find yourself in this position, you’ll need a lot of support. Postnatal doulas can be an incredible calming and practical presence if you don’t have other loving adults around. Remember than never in human history have you been expected to parent on your own.
You need an exit strategy for this. Talk to me or another lactation specialist about your goals and what’s achievable. Remember that mixed feeding can be awesome.
6. The impact of formula
We’ve seen the headlines, the hospital ward posters, the social media posts. You know that breastfeeding is best for your baby. You might be worried that formula will make your baby sick, less clever, obese or diabetic in later life. This is a lot of psychological and social pressure to put on parents.
I am not going to lie to you, there are lots of benefits of breastmilk and compelling evidence of it superiority to formula. But that’s not the same as saying that your decisions now will make your baby sick later. There are, for example, many factors leading to a national increase in type 2 diabetes. It’s a complex health and societal issue.
Breastmilk is an incredible substance. It helps your baby towards optimal development and protects them on many levels. Any breast milk you’ve been able to give is like extra medicine for your baby. You can celebrate that. And your formula fed baby will also be fine.
Remember that a lot of published information is not properly informed or nuanced. No scientific journal will publish a pro-formula study. Most of the research into formula is, by necessity, funded by the manufacturers. There are benefits to formula feeding. It’s hard to put a value on more rested, mentally well parents, on the joys of sharing parenting, on the gift of having a healthy alternative to breastmilk when, for whatever reason, it’s not available.
In the end it is all about balance. We cannot remove all risks from life. We have a lot less control than we think. If you care for your baby you’re already getting them off to a great start
7. Colic, gas, reflex, allergy, intolerance
However you feed your baby, you are likely to worry that they’re uncomfortable. Babies cry, fuss, strain, spit up and pass wind from both ends, and it seems to get worse in the first few weeks. So many parents worry about colic, gas, reflux and allergy that I wrote a whole blog about it here.
To set your mind at rest, there’s rarely anything wrong. We often have unrealistic expectations that our babies will feed and then go to sleep on their back wherever we put them. They don’t. Read more about it here.
Meanwhile, we’re sleep deprived and anxious. When our babies are upset we are designed to respond. Their cries feels unbearable to us and jangle our nerves as they’re meant to. It’s exhausting and overwhelming at times. We feel like we’re going to be stuck with our newborn only sleeping in our arms for ever.
We can help our babies with responsive bottle feeding, often with them in an elevated side lying position. Less winding is probably better than more.
If you’re worried about your baby then talk to your health care professionals. It’s estimated that about 3% of babies will react to cows or goats milk proteins, a miniscule number cannot deal with lactose, almost all spit up and complain about gas. They grow out of it.
It’s often your own health and wellbeing that needs focus. Becoming a parent is really hard!
8. Bottle preference
Healthcare professionals tend to terrify parents into not giving bottles for fear of undermining breastfeeding. Parents worry that even one bottle might put their baby off the breast.
There is less evidence around this than you might think. Most new babies take both breast and bottle. Sucking anything can help babies who are struggling with feeding. I meet more bottle refusers than breast refusers. It’s nuanced. If your baby needs a bottle then please go ahead and feed them with one.
If you want to maintain your milk supply you will need to pump milk to make up for the missed breastfeeds. For a newborn this means pumping about eight times in 24 hours. If that’s not possible, in the early days it is still sensible not to leave more than four to five hours between feeds or pumps. Full breasts make less milk. There’s more about how to introduce a bottle to a breastfed baby here.
If it’s vital your baby to take a bottle in the future, I would suggest you start practicing from four to six weeks in. There is more about the process here.
9. Bottle refusal
There’s a lot on social media about babies who will not drink from bottles, or are very upset by them. This can be very frightening for parents who are running out of feeding options. And of course there’s yet more guilt when we think we have caused these problems somehow.
Breastfeeding babies who can’t or seemingly won’t drink from a bottle are referred to as bottle refusers. This seems a bit unfair to the babies. Generally they don’t have the bottle skills and need to develop them. Or they sensibly associate the breast with calm emotional regulation as well as food, and have opinions about how they like to feed. There is a lot we can do with teamwork to help these babies. The right bottle, position and approach can work wonders. For reasons your baby refuses a bottle, read my article here.
10. Bottle aversion
Bottle averse babies tend to be almost exclusively bottle fed. These babies appear to associate bottle feeding with negative experiences, and can become incredibly upset with the feeding process. They may cry when they see a bottle or are held in a bottle feeding position. When given a bottle they can become hysterical. Or they take 30-60 ml and then utterly refuse to entertain the bottle any more.
Parents with bottle averse babies are often at their wits end. They are terrified they their baby will not take the required amount, and can’t go out for fear of their baby crying. They tend to be stuck in the house or to rush back for every feed. Some resort to feeding their baby while baby is asleep. They’ve had numerous appointments with the GP or paediatrician and may have their baby on medication for allergy or reflux, but nothing seems to help.
These are complex cases and need some skilled and sensitive support. We need to make sure that the baby is clinically OK. Then there are strategies to help these little ones make friends with the bottle again. It takes time and it’s great to have an experienced professional alongside you.
For babies that really don’t get on with bottles we do have other options. Tiny ones can be cup fed if necessary. After about four months we can use open and sippy cups. After about seven months we can teach them to drink with a straw.
In summary
I hope this has helped to show you what’s in the heads of other bottle feeding parents.
You deserve compassionate support on your bottle feeding journey. Please reach out for a face to face or virtual appointment if you’d like me to help.
Big hugs.
